Is it really worthy to measure product carbon footprint performing LCA?
Carbon Management
Explore the advantages of Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) over Product Carbon Footprint (PCF) for sustainable business practices and decision-making.
Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) helps businesses measure environmental impacts across a product's entire lifecycle - from raw materials to disposal.
Product Carbon Footprint (PCF) focuses on carbon emissions, offering a simpler, faster way to address climate-related goals.
LCA provides deeper insights, helping identify "hotspots" (e.g., supply chains contributing 80% of impacts) and guiding smarter design choices.
Consumers care: 60% are willing to pay more for sustainable packaging, and 32% trust brands with transparent supply chains.
Costs can be high (€5,000–€100,000+), but tools like Devera automate the process, making it faster and affordable for small businesses.
Real-world results: MUD Jeans cut CO₂ by 66% and water use by 80% using LCA insights.
Quick Comparison: LCA vs. PCF
Aspect | Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) | Product Carbon Footprint (PCF) |
---|---|---|
Scope | Broad (multiple environmental factors) | Narrow (carbon emissions only) |
Time Investment | More time-intensive | Faster execution |
Standards | ISO 14040, 14044 | ISO 14067 |
Applications | Supply chain optimization, compliance | Carbon labeling, emissions cuts |
Expertise Needed | Higher | Lower |
Both methods have their place: PCF is ideal for quick wins, while LCA is better for comprehensive sustainability strategies. Start small, focus on high-impact areas, and leverage automated tools to simplify the process.
Related video from YouTube
Life Cycle Assessment: Core Functions
Understanding the main functions of Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) helps determine its value as an investment. LCA systematically evaluates and minimizes environmental impact, aligning with the expectations of 81% of consumers who prioritize corporate sustainability.
LCA Step-by-Step Process
The ISO 14040 and 14044 standards outline four key phases for conducting a thorough LCA:
Phase | Key Activities | Role in Decision Making |
---|---|---|
Goal and Scope Definition | Define boundaries and functional units | Pinpoints which production aspects to analyze |
Life Cycle Inventory Analysis | Gather data on materials, energy, and emissions | Provides measurable metrics for improvement |
Impact Assessment | Assess environmental effects and carbon equivalents | Highlights areas for reduction efforts |
Results Interpretation | Evaluate findings and create action plans | Informs strategic sustainability initiatives |
For example, during the inventory analysis phase, companies track raw materials, energy consumption, emissions, and waste. These steps demonstrate how LCA provides actionable insights into environmental performance.
Benefits of LCA
LCA offers businesses practical advantages, including:
Spotting Carbon Hotspots: In T-shirt production, nearly half of carbon emissions stem from electricity used in manufacturing, while cotton fiber production accounts for about 18%.
Informed Design Choices: Data from LCA helps assess materials and production processes to create more sustainable products.
Strategic Planning: Understanding the full environmental footprint enables companies to focus on adopting green energy and optimizing processes.
Real-World Examples of LCA
Practical applications highlight the value of LCA. For instance, MUD Jeans' 2019 assessment showed that raw materials and manufacturing each contributed 42% to their overall impact. Using these insights, they achieved:
66% lower CO₂ emissions compared to Levi’s equivalent products
80% reduction in water usage
48% decrease in land use
Similarly, Nike's Considered Design shoe project identified ways to incorporate environmentally preferred materials and processes, significantly reducing the environmental impact of their footwear compared to standard models.
These examples illustrate that while LCA requires resources, it delivers actionable insights that lead to measurable environmental improvements and competitive advantages.
Common LCA Obstacles
While LCA (Life Cycle Assessment) offers numerous advantages, its implementation often comes with challenges related to data, costs, and regulatory compliance. These hurdles can make adoption difficult for many organizations.
Data Challenges
Collecting and managing data is one of the biggest obstacles in LCA. Without standardized databases for environmental impact data, conducting accurate assessments becomes a significant challenge.
Here are some common data-related issues:
Challenge | Impact | Possible Solution |
---|---|---|
Data Quality | Incomplete or outdated data can distort results | Implement systematic data collection processes |
Format Inconsistency | Different file formats complicate analysis | Use standardized software platforms |
Database Variations | Emission factors vary across sources | Focus on collecting primary data |
These data issues often lead to further complications when combined with the time and financial demands of LCA.
Time and Financial Constraints
The cost of conducting an LCA can be a major barrier, especially for small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). A simplified LCA typically costs between €5,000 and €20,000, while a more detailed analysis can exceed €50,000–€100,000. For SMEs, which are responsible for 60–70% of global environmental pollution, these costs can be prohibitive. Additionally, 72% of SMEs report lacking trained LCA staff, and 41% face difficulties in acquiring the necessary data.
Navigating Standards and Regulations
Complying with international standards adds another layer of complexity. The ISO 14040 series requires strict adherence to standardized methodologies, including detailed documentation of data collection methods, assumptions, and calculations.
For example, California's Buy Clean Act mandates that state agencies incorporate embodied carbon considerations into infrastructure materials via verified LCAs. While specialized software can help automate calculations and streamline compliance, it also requires additional investment in training and infrastructure. These regulatory demands highlight the importance of efficient tools and methods for conducting LCAs effectively throughout the product lifecycle.
Making LCA Easier
New tools are simplifying Life Cycle Assessment (LCA), addressing earlier challenges like data handling, costs, and regulatory hurdles. These advancements make the process faster, more affordable, and precise.
Devera: Automated LCA Platform
Devera tackles common LCA obstacles for small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). Its AI-driven system reduces the need for manual data collection.
"This tool can replace costly consulting services"
Traditional LCA | Devera Automated LCA |
---|---|
6‑month completion time | Faster processing |
Manual data collection | Automated data capture |
High consulting costs | Flexible pricing |
Limited reassessment | Simple updates |
Other platforms also use automation to make LCA easier and more efficient.
Software Solutions for LCA
One Click LCA showcases automation through these steps:
Import: Pull design data directly from BIM, energy models, or spreadsheets
Process: Automatically align LCA results with certification standards
Optimize: Use built-in tools to pinpoint areas for improvement
Tips for Small Businesses
Automated tools aren't just about simplifying assessments - they help small businesses take meaningful action based on sustainability insights:
Use LCA templates to define goals and analyze data inventories
Build a system for collecting industry-relevant data to ensure accuracy
Monitor progress with standardized templates for easy comparisons
"This product is a powerful differentiator for e-commerce businesses and brands aiming to outshine their competitors"
Platforms like Devera can increase assessment capacity dramatically - up to 1,000 times more - making LCA accessible for businesses of every size.
LCA vs PCF: Key Differences
Understanding the differences between Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) and Product Carbon Footprint (PCF) is crucial for businesses aiming to measure and manage their environmental impact effectively.
Scope and Focus
LCA examines a wide range of environmental factors, including water usage, acidification, human toxicity, and resource depletion, providing a broad analysis of environmental impacts. For instance, studies show that electric vehicles emit over 60% fewer pollutants than gas-powered cars over their lifetime when analyzed through LCA.
PCF, on the other hand, focuses exclusively on greenhouse gas emissions, measured in CO2 equivalents. This makes it a practical choice for companies aiming to address climate-related goals quickly and communicate results clearly to stakeholders. However, its narrower focus may miss other environmental concerns.
Method Comparison Table
Here’s a quick breakdown of the main differences between PCF and LCA:
Aspect | Product Carbon Footprint (PCF) | Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) |
---|---|---|
Primary Focus | Carbon emissions only | Multiple environmental impacts |
Time Investment | Faster execution | More time-intensive |
Standard Compliance | ISO 14067 | ISO 14040 and ISO 14044 |
Typical Applications | Carbon labeling, emissions reduction | Regulatory compliance, supply chain optimization |
Resource Requirements | Lower expertise needed | Higher expertise required |
Analysis Depth | Single impact metric | Comprehensive environmental assessment |
PCF is a quicker and simpler tool for targeting carbon emissions, making it ideal for businesses with specific climate goals. LCA, however, provides a more detailed and holistic view, helping organizations avoid shifting problems from one environmental area to another. This makes LCA particularly valuable for crafting well-rounded sustainability strategies.
Making the Decision
Key Factors to Consider
Before diving into Life Cycle Assessment (LCA), take a close look at these important factors:
Decision Factor | What to Think About |
---|---|
Data Availability | Do you have access to reliable primary data? How good is the existing data quality? |
Resource Investment | Can your budget cover tools, expertise, and the time needed for implementation? |
Business Goals | Does LCA align with your sustainability targets and any regulatory requirements? |
Product Complexity | How many components and how deep is your supply chain? |
Market Demands | Are customers or competitors driving the need for LCA adoption? |
These factors highlight the core elements to evaluate when considering LCA. It's worth noting that up to 90% of a consumer product company's environmental impact comes from the production and sale of its products.
Practical Recommendations
Once you've evaluated the factors above, here are some actionable steps to get started:
Start Small: Begin with a pilot project focused on your most critical product line. This helps manage costs and build internal expertise.
Focus on High-Impact Areas: Prioritize "hotspots" where improvements can make the biggest difference.
Use the Right Tools: Look into automated solutions like Devera, which can simplify the process while ensuring compliance with ISO standards.
Tailor your LCA approach to your company's unique needs. For example, Dow Chemical's 10-year S-ROI plan is projected to save the company $1 billion.
The Future of LCA
LCA is evolving quickly, driven by new technologies and stricter regulations.
"By using LCA correctly and adhering to international standards, LCA can be one of the most important tools for sustainability managers to consider when setting out the sustainability strategy for your company".
"LCA doesn't just offer surface-level insights. It dives deep into every stage of a product's life cycle, from raw material extraction to disposal, showing businesses where they can make impactful changes".
Informed decisions are the foundation of successful LCA implementation. By understanding the full life cycle of your products, you can uncover opportunities for meaningful improvements.
Related Blog Posts
Cosmetic brands sustainability reports and LCA calculations: the very best practices.
EU Green Claims Directive Explained